The Music Critic Indie category now features reviews of 1559 albums, with more being added all the time.
Sort by :
Release Date | Best New Releases | Best Indie of all time | Alphabetically
Now showing the 50 best reviewed Indie Albums out of the last 100 releases, with the highest scoring shown at the top
- 87
Kaputt
Destroyer
Released Jan 25, 2011
Genre: Pop/Rock - 87
This Is Happening
LCD Soundsystem
Released May 18, 2010
Genre: Indie - 86
Black Tambourine
Black Tambourine
Released Mar 30, 2010
Genre: Indie - 85
Microshift
Hookworms
Released Feb 2, 2018
Genre: Pop/Rock - 85
Treats
Sleigh Bells
Released Jun 1, 2010
Genre: Indie - 84
High Violet
The National
Released May 11, 2010
Genre: Indie - 84
Jericho Sirens
Hot Snakes
Released Mar 16, 2018
Genre: Pop/Rock - 83
Present Tense
Wild Beasts
Released Feb 25, 2014
Genre: Pop/Rock - 83
Before Today
Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti
Released Jun 8, 2010
Genre: Indie - 82
Majesty Shredding
Superchunk
Released Sep 14, 2010
Genre: Pop/Rock - 81
Dark Night Of The Soul
Danger Mouse And Sparklehorse
Released Jul 13, 2010
Genre: Indie - 81
Hidden
These New Puritans
Released Mar 2, 2010
Genre: Indie - 80
Poison Season
Destroyer
Released Aug 28, 2015
Genre: Pop/Rock - 80
Fallen House Sunken City
B. Dolan
Released Mar 2, 2010
Genre: Indie - 80
Real Britannia
Ultrasound
Released Dec 2, 2016
Genre: Indie - 80
Punk Drunk And Trembling [EP]
Wild Beasts
Released Oct 20, 2017
Genre: Pop/Rock - 80
I Hate Music
Superchunk
Released Aug 20, 2013
Genre: Pop/Rock - 79
The Wondershow Of The World
Bonnie "Prince" Billy & The Cairo Gang
Released Mar 23, 2010
Genre: Indie - 79
Superorganism
Superorganism
Released Mar 2, 2018
Genre: Pop/Rock - 78
Nothing Hurts
Male Bonding
Released May 11, 2010
Genre: Indie - 78
Clinging To A Scheme
The Radio Dept.
Released Apr 20, 2010
Genre: Indie - 78
Smother
Wild Beasts
Released May 10, 2011
Genre: Pop/Rock - 77
Preoccupations
Preoccupations
Released Sep 16, 2016
Genre: Pop/Rock - 77
The Monitor
Titus Andronicus
Released Mar 9, 2010
Genre: Indie - 77
In The Court Of The Wrestling Let's
Let's Wrestle
Released Mar 23, 2010
Genre: Indie - 77
Rough Travel For A Rare Thing [Live]
Bill Callahan
Released Mar 23, 2010
Genre: Indie - 77
Love This Giant
David Byrne & St. Vincent
Released Sep 11, 2012
Genre: Indie - 77
What We Lose In The Fire We Gain In The Flood
The Mynabirds
Released Apr 27, 2010
Genre: Indie - 76
Forgiveness Rock Record
Broken Social Scene
Released May 4, 2010
Genre: Indie - 76
New Material
Preoccupations
Released Mar 23, 2018
Genre: Pop/Rock - 76
Total Life Forever
Foals
Released Jun 15, 2010
Genre: Indie - 76
Happy Birthday
Happy Birthday
Released Mar 16, 2010
Genre: Indie - 76
Volume Two
She & Him
Released Mar 23, 2010
Genre: Indie - 76
Ken
Destroyer
Released Oct 20, 2017
Genre: Pop/Rock - 75
Blue Sky Noise
Circa Survive
Released Apr 20, 2010
Genre: Indie - 75
Last Night All My Dreams Came True
Wild Beasts
Released Feb 16, 2018
Genre: Pop/Rock - 75
Here's To Taking It Easy
Phosphorescent
Released May 11, 2010
Genre: Indie - 75
Compass
Jamie Lidell
Released May 18, 2010
Genre: Indie - 75
Becoming A Jackal
Villagers
Released Jun 8, 2010
Genre: Indie - 75
Two Thousand And Ten Injuries
Love Is All
Released Mar 23, 2010
Genre: Indie - 75
Acoustic Recordings 1998-2016
Jack White
Released Sep 9, 2016
Genre: Pop/Rock - 75
Boys Outside
Steve Mason
Released Jun 22, 2010
Genre: Indie - 73
Paul's Tomb: A Triumph
Frog Eyes
Released Apr 27, 2010
Genre: Indie - 73
Always Ascending
Franz Ferdinand
Released Feb 9, 2018
Genre: Pop/Rock - 73
Pigeons
Here We Go Magic
Released Jun 8, 2010
Genre: Indie - 72
Saint Bartlett
Damien Jurado
Released May 25, 2010
Genre: Indie - 72
Communicating
Hundred Waters
Released Sep 14, 2017
Genre: Indie - 71
Thing
Trans Am
Released Apr 20, 2010
Genre: Indie - 71
The Winter Of Mixed Drinks
Frightened Rabbit
Released Mar 9, 2010
Genre: Indie - 71
Hippies
Harlem
Released Apr 6, 2010
Genre: Indie