The Music Critic Indie category now features reviews of 1559 albums, with more being added all the time.
Sort by :
Release Date | Best New Releases | Best Indie of all time | Alphabetically
Now showing all Indie Album reviews on Music Critic, with the highest scoring shown at the top.
- 100
Untrue
Burial
Released Nov 6, 2007
Genre: Indie - 100
Strange House
The Horrors
Released May 15, 2007
Genre: Indie - 100
Funeral
Arcade Fire
Released Sep 14, 2004
Genre: Indie - 100
Now Here Is Nowhere
Secret Machines
Released May 18, 2004
Genre: Indie - 100
Franz Ferdinand
Franz Ferdinand
Released Mar 9, 2004
Genre: Indie - 100
Rounds
Four Tet
Released May 6, 2003
Genre: Indie - 95
Ys
Joanna Newsom
Released Nov 14, 2006
Genre: Indie - 95
Tales From Turnpike House
Saint Etienne
Released Jan 24, 2006
Genre: Indie - 95
From A Basement On The Hill
Elliott Smith
Released Oct 19, 2004
Genre: Indie - 92
The Sound Of The Smiths
The Smiths
Released Nov 11, 2008
Genre: Indie - 91
Merriweather Post Pavilion
Animal Collective
Released Jan 20, 2009
Genre: Indie - 91
The Airing Of Grievances
Titus Andronicus
Released May 13, 2008
Genre: Indie - 90
Ten Kens
Ten Kens
Released Sep 23, 2008
Genre: Indie - 90
Courtcase 2000
Cats In Paris
Released Aug 25, 2008
Genre: Indie - 90
Do You Like Rock Music?
British Sea Power
Released Feb 12, 2008
Genre: Indie - 90
Hey Venus!
Super Furry Animals
Released Jan 22, 2008
Genre: Indie - 90
The Shepherd's Dog
Iron & Wine
Released Sep 25, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
Hey Hey My My Yo Yo
Junior Senior
Released Aug 14, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga
Spoon
Released Jul 10, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
The Fragile Army
The Polyphonic Spree
Released Jun 19, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
It's A Bit Complicated
Art Brut
Released Jun 19, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
Excellent Italian Greyhound
Shellac
Released Jun 5, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
Mirrored
Battles
Released May 22, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
Tears Of The Valedictorian
Frog Eyes
Released May 1, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
You, You're A History In Rust
Do Make Say Think
Released Feb 27, 2007
Genre: Indie - 90
Roots & Crowns
Califone
Released Oct 10, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Be Still Please
Portastatic
Released Oct 10, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
This Harness Can't Ride Anything
Chin Up Chin Up
Released Oct 10, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Boys And Girls In America
The Hold Steady
Released Oct 3, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Gang Of Losers
The Dears
Released Oct 3, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
The Letting Go
Bonnie "Prince" Billy
Released Sep 19, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Taiga
OOIOO
Released Sep 12, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
The Obliterati
Mission of Burma
Released May 23, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
The Spell
The Black Heart Procession
Released May 9, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Zeroes And Ones
Eleventh Dream Day
Released Apr 25, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Introduction
The Red Krayola
Released Apr 18, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Elan Vital
Pretty Girls Make Graves
Released Apr 11, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Jacket Full Of Danger
Adam Green
Released Apr 10, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
DFA Remixes: Chapter 1
The DFA
Released Apr 4, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Dancing With Daggers
Magneta Lane
Released Apr 4, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
'Sno Angel Like You
Howe Gelb
Released Mar 21, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Bring It Back
Mates of State
Released Mar 21, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Cannibal Sea
The Essex Green
Released Mar 21, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Love Travels At Illegal Speeds
Graham Coxon
Released Mar 13, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Fox Confessor Brings The Flood
Neko Case
Released Mar 7, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
From A Compound Eye
Robert Pollard
Released Jan 24, 2006
Genre: Indie - 90
Oh You're So Silent Jens
Jens Lekman
Released Nov 22, 2005
Genre: Indie - 90
Hypermagic Mountain
Lightning Bolt
Released Oct 18, 2005
Genre: Indie - 90
Tanglewood Numbers
Silver Jews
Released Oct 18, 2005
Genre: Indie - 90
Tournament Of Hearts
The Constantines
Released Oct 11, 2005
Genre: Indie