Side-by-side comparison

We take a look at two popular items, the   YAMAHA YAS-280 Saxophones Student Alto and the  Roy Benson RBAS302 Eb Professional Alto Saxophone. The team take this task very seriously - two products enter, but only one can leave. Click here if you would like to see more product reviews in the same category.

  YAMAHA YAS-280 Saxophones Student AltoEveryone has different preferences and priorities, so to make choosing easier we have attempted to give a frank review of the products. Let's start with the   YAMAHA YAS-280 Saxophones Student Alto. Yamaha is a name that is familiar to people across the world whether you play a musical instrument or not. The Yamaha corporation is based in Japan and offers an enormous list of products and services. Easily one of the biggest companies in the world and a household name.

  Roy Benson RBAS302 Eb Professional Alto SaxophoneThe second product we are looking at in this head-to-head review is the  Roy Benson RBAS302 Eb Professional Alto Saxophone. Roy Benson are well known for their high quality, German engineered saxophones. They have been releasing fantastic horns for over 15 years now and their products are famous for their great craftsmanship and affordable price tags.

A good look at the   YAMAHA YAS-280 Saxophones Student Alto

Their musical instruments are known for their quality and style and cover countless categories like guitar and bass, drums, violins for beginners, brass, and woodwind. Their pianos and keyboards, in particular, are very famous and are known the world over for being innovative and of the highest quality.

Examining the  Roy Benson RBAS302 Eb Professional Alto Saxophone

The RBAS302 really is an impressive alto saxophone and is full of great features. It boasts an RND (relaxed neck design) neck, bar mounted keys, an elegantly designed brass body, and brass keys that are joyfully easy to play. The high range is F sharp and it sports a C sharp - B flat connected table key and hardened steel springs for a great playing feel.


  YAMAHA YAS-280 Saxophones Student Alto

 Roy Benson RBAS302 Eb Professional Alto Saxophone


+ Yamaha branded product
+ One of the better beginner saxophones on the market
+ Super simple to play and sounds great

+ High-quality alto saxophone
+ Very affordable
+ Excellent accessories


As close to a must buy saxophone for beginners as you can get. It ticks all the boxes in terms of what to look for in a student saxophone with the added peace of mind that it bears the Yamaha brand name.

This would be a good purchase for nearly any player. The quality of the sax combined with the price tag means it is a great ‘every-man’ alto saxophone.

The Bottom Line

Check out our article 10 Best Alto Saxophones in 2023 for more info.

Similar head-to-head comparisons: