Through The Windowpane

Album Review of Through The Windowpane by Guillemots.

Home » Indie » Through The Windowpane

Through The Windowpane


Through The Windowpane by Guillemots

Release Date: Jul 10, 2006
Record label: Polydor
Genre(s): Indie, Rock, Pop

60 Music Critic Score
How the Music Critic Score works

Through The Windowpane - Average, Based on 2 Critics

The Guardian - 60
Based on rating 3/5

Is that pronounced "gillmots" or "gee-mo"? Arguments rage, but after three attempts to finish their debut, Birmingham's most oddly named band make the classic mistake of all new major-label signings following a bidding war. It's a wonder any of their songs emerge intact from the production soufflé engendered by the label's big studio, which provided everything from school playground noises to recorded seagulls. But emerge they do - both because of and in spite of singer Fyfe Dangerfield, who doesn't always have the hooks on which to hang his vocal gymnastics.

Full Review >>

AllMusic - 60
Based on rating 6/10

With their EP From the Cliffs, the Guillemots introduced themselves as daring, energetic, inventive performers for whom traditional pop notions of harmony and rhythm could be discarded, or at least tweaked, if a better opportunity presented itself. And despite all the warning signs of pretension and inaccessibility, the Guillemots were able to create in From the Cliffs something that was very listenable and fun. Of course, there were problems, but they were problems of over-ambition and -eagerness, and they seemed easy enough to remedy without disrupting the band's rather intricate overall sound.

Full Review >>